Fund Monitors Pty Ltd
© Copyright 2024
Printed: 20 April 2024 6:04 PM


1 Mar 2024 - Looking through the headline noise

By: Ox Capital (Fidante Partners)

Looking through the headline noise

Ox Capital (Fidante Partners)

February 2024

Reality vs. sentiment

We are seeing a clear dislocation between reality and stock market sentiment. Contrary to news headlines of a lacklustre macro-economic environment and outlook, quality companies continue to execute and grow earnings. The overall economy is resilient and showing pockets of strength. Headwinds to the property market are manageable and well understood.  Our base case is the Chinese economy will grow this year (4.5% to low 5% range) and we continue to expect the Chinese authorities to provide support for the economy to restore confidence. After sharp pullbacks in Chinese equities, the authorities are intervening, introducing various measures to support the stock market.  It's important to look through the noise. 

Return of the flow. Daily volumes of on shore ETFs have spiked. This is important, as the National Team (China's Sovereign Fund) has proactively intervened with direct purchase of equities/ETFs to support the market. The Sovereign fund also vows to further increase ETF holdings to support the market as needed. This reminds us of when the Hong Kong government stepped in during the Asian Crisis to support the market and uphold stability.

Source: Bloomberg, Bofa Securities (MEGA)

Recurring headlines are somewhat old news. Despite recent headlines, the Chinese property downturn is in fact quite advanced. This is a well-known fact as sales are down over 40% since peak. Developer loans exposure to the baking system is low (less than 6%). Distressed developers have defaulted, while contagion to the trust industry is low and very manageable.  The news of property developer Evergrande's inevitable collapse was well known despite recent articles highlighting its demise. Again, it's important to look through the noise. The government extending support for local developers (both private and state owned) through banks with measures to improve developers' liquidity will further improve confidence. Moreover, China's real estate investment relative to GDP remains one of the lowest relative to other major economies while sales are approaching sustainable levels after years of declines.

Finally, the government continues to show willingness to provide support by easing policy further. The PSL (China's version of QE) grew in December and January to fund urban village redevelopment and social housing. In addition, the PBoC recently lowered the deposit reserve ratio requirements of financial institutions by 0.5%, in-line with prior guidance of further monetary policy easing. As such, the reduction in reserve requirements will provide liquidity, benefiting the real estate market and economy overall, supporting consumer confidence even further.  We do acknowledge however, the stimulus measures all up (including urban redevelopment, lower mortgage rates, ect..) will take time to fully restore confidence and strengthen the economic outlook.  

Source: NBS, Morgan Stanley Research

China is not Japan's "Lost Decade": There have been a recent uptick in headlines and concerns that China's outlook is similar to Japan in the 1990s when there was a period of economic stagnation and a significant slow-down in economic activity and the asset bubble eventually collapsed.  Notable differences:

  • China's GDP per capita (12K) is much lower than that of Japan in the 1990s
  • China's property bubble is not as large as Japan's during that period
  • The ratio of real estate to GDP has declined and much lower than Japan was in the 90s
  • Limited gains in stock prices over the past decade for Chinese indices

Right now, valuations for Chinese equities are at depressed levels, and at a time when government authorities are dedicated to restoring confidence and reinvigorating the economy. Quality businesses will continue to grow and become champion businesses in coming years. Now is the time to invest and take advantage of the very attractive valuations. As we have stated previously, it is important to consider the multiple catalysts and act now given 1) valuations are extremely cheap, 2) property market is stabilising, 3) China QE "PSL" is supporting the economy (and restoring confidence) at this juncture, 4) Chinese capital replacing international flows in Hong Kong equities market, 5) National Team providing stability, and 6) geopolitical stabilisation.

Funds operated by this manager:

Ox Capital Dynamic Emerging Markets Fund

Australian Fund Monitors Pty Ltd
A.C.N. 122 226 724
AFSL 324476
Email: [email protected]